Joint Tenants vs. Tenants in Common: Why Understanding the Difference Could Shape Your Future
- Anna Kmiec
- Mar 22
- 6 min read
Updated: Jul 22
When it comes to buying property with someone else—be it your spouse, partner, friend, business associate, or family member—it’s easy to get caught up in the excitement. You've found the perfect home, maybe a cute fixer-upper with a garden, or a sleek apartment with city views. You're planning the move, imagining furniture layouts, and debating kitchen styles. But in the midst of all this, there’s one critical decision you might overlook: how you own the property legally.
You’ve likely heard the terms Joint Tenants and Tenants in Common. They might sound like legal jargon that doesn’t concern you—until it suddenly does. The way you choose to hold property can have lasting consequences on inheritance, taxes, divorce settlements, or selling the property. In some cases, it could mean the difference between a smooth transition and a legal nightmare for your loved ones.
Let’s break it down in simple terms, using life examples to show just how important this decision really is.
The Basics: What Do These Terms Mean?
What is Joint Tenancy?
In a joint tenancy, both parties (or all parties, if more than two) own the whole property together. There are no separate shares. Everyone has an undivided interest in the entire property, and it operates under the principle of "rights of survivorship."
What does this mean?
You both have equal rights to the entire property.
If one person dies, the surviving owner(s) automatically inherit the deceased's share—regardless of what the Will says.
You cannot leave your share to someone else in a Will.
What is Tenancy in Common?
Tenants in common own individual shares in a property. These shares don’t have to be equal—one person could own 70%, the other 30%, for example. Each person can leave their share to whoever they want in their Will. There's no automatic inheritance.
In simple terms:
Each owner has a distinct share.
Shares can be equal or unequal.
When an owner dies, their share becomes part of their estate and is distributed according to their Will (or intestacy rules if there’s no Will).
You can leave your share to a child, a partner, or even a charity.
Life Scenarios: Why It Matters
To illustrate how critical this choice is, let’s look at a few scenarios. These are fictional but based on very real situations people face every day.
Scenario 1: Sarah and Mark – The Married Couple Without a Will
Sarah and Mark, a married couple in their late 40s, buy their family home together and register it as joint tenants. They never get around to writing Wills, assuming everything will go to their spouse anyway.
Sadly, Mark passes away unexpectedly in a car accident.
What happens?
Because they owned the home as joint tenants, Sarah automatically inherits the whole property, even without a Will. This is a case where joint tenancy works smoothly. There’s no need for probate for that asset, and no confusion about who inherits.
However, if they had owned it as tenants in common, and Mark had no Will, things could have gone differently. His share of the property would pass according to intestacy laws—potentially splitting it between Sarah and their children, or other relatives, depending on the estate value.
Lesson: Joint tenancy offers simplicity for married couples or partners who want automatic inheritance.
Scenario 2: David and Liam – Friends Buying Their First Investment Property
David and Liam, best friends from university, decide to buy a rental property together. David contributes 70% of the down payment; Liam contributes 30%. They decide to split profits based on investment, and both want to retain flexibility to leave their share to their own families later.
What should they choose?
Tenants in common.
This structure allows them to hold unequal shares and ensures that if something happens to one of them, their share doesn’t automatically go to the other. Instead, it can go to a sibling, parent, or even be sold.
What happens if they had chosen joint tenancy instead?
Liam would inherit David’s share (or vice versa), even though they might not have intended this. That could create awkward situations with grieving family members or legal disputes.
Lesson: For business partners or friends investing together, tenants in common is usually the smarter, safer option.
Scenario 3: Emma – Second Marriage and Protecting Her Children’s Inheritance
Emma, in her late 50s, marries John after being widowed. They buy a home together and move in. Emma has two adult children from her previous marriage, and she wants to ensure they inherit her share of the property eventually.
Which ownership type suits her best?
Tenants in common.
Why? If Emma passes away and the home is held as joint tenants, John automatically inherits the entire property—even if her Will says otherwise. Her children would be left out unless John chooses to include them later (which, legally, he wouldn't be obligated to do).
With tenants in common, Emma can specify in her Will that her share goes to her children. John can continue to live in the property (perhaps with a life interest trust), but her children's inheritance is protected.
Lesson: Blended families should think carefully about ownership types and estate planning.
Switching from Joint Tenants to Tenants in Common: It’s Not Too Late
Already own a home as joint tenants but realising that tenants in common might be more suitable for your situation? The good news: you can change it.
This process is called a severance of tenancy and typically involves:
Completing a form called a Notice of Severance.
Informing the other party.
Notifying the Land Registry to update the title.
It's relatively straightforward and often handled by solicitors or Will writers, especially if you're updating your estate plans at the same time.
How to Check How You Own Your Property
If you’re unsure how your property is held - If your property is registered with the Land Registry (which most are, if purchased in recent years), you or your solicitor can check the title register.
Better yet—ask your Will Writer or conveyancing solicitor to clarify it during your next review.
Why It Really Matters
Let’s pause for a moment and ask the real question: Why should you care about all this?
Because the choice between joint tenants and tenants in common affects:
Who inherits your property
How your estate is taxed
What happens if you break up or divorce
Who gets a say in selling or refinancing
Your ability to protect children from previous relationships
Estate planning flexibility
How quickly or smoothly probate goes
Think of it this way: you wouldn’t leave your front door unlocked when you leave the house. Similarly, don’t leave your most valuable asset unprotected simply because the legal details felt boring or confusing at the time of purchase.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can we change from tenants in common back to joint tenants?
A: Yes, but both parties must agree. It usually involves a transfer of equity.
Q: What happens if we’re tenants in common and one person wants to sell?
A: If there's a dispute, the matter can go to court. One party can force a sale through legal channels, though ideally, this is handled amicably or with the help of mediation.
Q: Is there a tax difference between the two?
A: There can be. With tenants in common, inheritance tax planning becomes more flexible, especially for larger estates or blended families.
Final Thoughts: Take Control of Your Property Future
Whether you’re buying your first home, investing in property with friends, or blending families in later life, choosing between joint tenancy and tenancy in common is more than a checkbox on a form. It’s a cornerstone of your financial, legal, and emotional future.
We often say that home is where the heart is—but it’s also where the law is. Taking the time to understand these ownership structures now can save your loved ones from stress, confusion, and potential conflict down the line.
If you’re not sure how you own your property or whether your current setup is still right for your situation, talk to a Will Writer, estate planner, or property solicitor. The right advice today can protect everything you’re building for tomorrow.
Still have questions?
We’re here to help. 😊 Reach out and let’s ensure your property ownership matches your goals, relationships, and long-term plans.
📅 Book online: Click here
📞 Call us: 01926 897077
Comments